Comparison
Looking for a Chargeflow alternative? Here's the honest comparison
Chargeflow is the category leader on the Shopify App Store, and for stores with high dispute volume that want full automation, it works as designed. This page is for the other segment: stores with 1–5 disputes a month that did the maths on a 25% success fee — or that want to personally approve anything submitted to a bank in their name.
Side by side
| Chargeflow | Evidkit | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | 25% of each recovered dispute | $29/mo flat |
| Cost on a $1,000 won dispute | $250 | $0 extra |
| Submission | Automatic ("autopilot") | Only after you approve, every time |
| Who clicks submit | The app | You |
| Touches your money | Handles the recovery flow | Never — drafts evidence only |
| Extras | Alerts, fraud scanning, prevention | Deadline reminders, audit log |
| Review base | 363 reviews / 4.8 | New app — we're the newcomer |
| Best for | High volume, hands-off | 1–5 disputes/mo, control-first |
The break-even
$29/mo flat versus a 25% success fee: if you recover more than about $116 a month, flat pricing is cheaper. One won $500 dispute pays for four months of Evidkit. Put your own volume in the calculator rather than taking our word for it.
When Chargeflow is the right choice — yes, really
- You have dozens of disputes a month and no time to review any of them.
- You want alerts, prevention, and recovery bundled with one vendor.
- You want to pay nothing in the months you lose everything.
- You want a long public review history before you install anything. We don't have one yet; they do.
When Evidkit is the right choice
- Your dispute volume is small enough that 25% of one big win exceeds a year of flat fees.
- You want to read what's being sent to your acquirer before it's sent — every time, as the default, not as an opt-in setting.
- You want a tool that structurally cannot move your money. Evidkit issues no refunds, takes no percentage, and initiates no transfers. The most it ever does is prepare evidence and wait for you.
Neither of us can promise you'll win. Issuing banks decide disputes, and the honest version of this whole category is that a tool improves your evidence and your deadline discipline — not your odds in any guaranteed sense.
Flat $29/mo, and nothing is submitted without your approval
Early access for Shopify Payments stores. 14-day free trial, no success fee, ever.
See how it worksDisclosure: Evidkit is our product, so treat the framing accordingly and check the numbers yourself. Chargeflow figures are quoted from their published pricing and App Store listing in August 2026 and may have changed. Chargeflow is a trademark of its owner; we are not affiliated with them, or with Shopify.